BALANCE wrote:This is not happening in the next few days but....
Hull is beige, current boot stripe is brown, bottom is blue - what's left of it. Sailcloth is brown. Bulwarks exterior are brown. Tim, I know you have deep felt opinions on all this.
At some point, I'd like to make the hull dark, either green or blue. In the meantime I was pondering a dark green bootstripe (I don't think this will be too weird with brown sailcloth). What color bottom would look good to a green boot stripe? Red seems to dark, teal doesn't seems right, nor does blue.
If I do change the color or the boot stripe, do I have to change the color of the bulwarks?
How soon do you anticipate being able to consider redoing the hull in the manner you really like?
I am not a big fan of brown, but given the overall look of your boat now, and the general mix of colors you have going on now, I'd suggest that you ought to leave well enough alone for the moment. The various shades of earth-toned colors work relatively well together, and as you mention, you can easily run into problems when trying to make a change to only one color of a whole color scheme.
But beyond that:
If you change the boottop, I believe the sheer strake (bulwarks) should be the same color.
The brown canvas might go with some other trim colors, but the whole package you have sort of works together, and I'd be wary of changing one thing without changing it all. (Yup, it's all connected, sorry!).
You need a contrast between the boottop color and the bottom color to give them some visual separation. With your boot butting up to the bottom paint, this limits your options with the color hull you have. Changing to green striping might be OK, but none of the bottom colors would look very good butting up directly to the boottop.
The only other interim option that occurs to me would be dark red (i.e. Claret) for your striping, sticking with the blue bottom that you have. The dark red would look better next to the blue bottom than green would and would have more contrast against it.
All in all, unless you're ready for a wholesale change, I might stick with what you have for now.